Methodology
CaseBond records true-crime history at the level of the individual claim. Every factual claim must cite at least one source we opened and checked; that requirement is enforced by the database itself, not by editorial habit.
How a claim earns its status
Reported
Cited & calm
Published with its sources. The default reading state — never a loud “unverified” stamp.
Corroborated
Triaged
Independent trusted outlets counted. Directs reviewer attention; decays when links rot.
Verified
Human seal ✓
A person checked it. Only a human action marks Verified — no automation ever promotes a claim.
Disputedthe “earned red” — the only loud state. Loudness scales with risk, never with absence of review.
↺ CorrectionEdit a claim and its prior verifications are voided — it returns to Reported and the change is logged permanently, append-only.
01
Verification is human-only
Community consensus can make a claim eligible, but only a human contributor's action marks anything Verified. No automation ever promotes a claim.
02
Corroboration is separate
We count how many independent trusted outlets — with live links — back a claim. Corroboration triages reviewer attention; it never substitutes for verification, and it decays automatically when links rot.
03
Corrections are public
When a claim's text changes, prior verifications are voided, the claim returns to unverified, and the correction is logged permanently — the log cannot be edited or deleted.
04
Legal floor
We never publish accusatory claims about private individuals who were not charged or convicted — and we treat acquitted and exonerated people as equally protected. This rule is enforced in the data layer and cannot be overridden by anyone, including us.
05
Contributor standing
Every signed-in contributor starts with a small baseline so their vote counts. Standing grows when verifications hold up and when someone catches one of our errors — that last one is weighted most. It eases off after a long time away and never drops below where you started. It is a trust signal that weights a vote, never a gate: more standing means more weight, not special permission.
Source lists shown on this site are the sources used and checked for each record — not an exhaustive, official, or consensus account.